> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theunredacted.co/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The CAIR–Muslim Brotherhood–Hamas Pipeline They Don't Want You to See
- URL: https://www.theunredacted.co/the-cair-muslim-brotherhood-hamas-pipeline-they-dont-want-you-to-see/
- Published: 2026-11-16T00:56:59.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T00:56:59.000Z
- Author: Gene Goodwin
- Tags: CAIR, DSA

> Mamdani’s Newly-Appointed NYC Chief Counsel Ramzi Kassem Calls on People to Donate to CAIR, While Accepting the Organization’s “Defender of Truth” Award, Adds: There’s a Steady Slide towards Authoritarianism in the U.S.; You Cannot Wait Out a Genocide; Zhara Billoo Is “a Treasure… [pic.twitter.com/hJxJ5SO1Xe](https://t.co/hJxJ5SO1Xe?ref=theunredacted.co)
> 
> — MEMRI (@MEMRIReports) [January 1, 2026](https://x.com/MEMRIReports/status/2006755942151385578?ref%5Fsrc=twsrc%5Etfw&ref=theunredacted.co)

The Unredacted · IntelligenceFollow the MoneyElection 2026Filed 14 Nov 2026

# A 1994 Agenda Lists CAIR Under Hamas's American Committee. Today It Has a Super PAC and $41 Million in Public Grants.

DataRepublican's thread lays out the lineage from the Muslim Brotherhood to CAIR and asks why Washington never acts on it. We checked every load-bearing claim. The court exhibits are real. Five details in the thread are wrong or stretched, one bill is misdescribed, and one sentence should never have been written.

Analysis · **Gene Goodwin**  
Source reporting · **DataRepublican (@DataRepublican) · Intelligent Advocacy Network · Network Contagion Research Institute**

###### Credit where it is owed

The spine of this report is **DataRepublican's** thread, "The CAIR, Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas Pipeline," which pulled the Holy Land Foundation exhibits back into public view. The grant records came from the **Intelligent Advocacy Network** and the **Network Contagion Research Institute**. City Journal's Ryan Thorpe and Christopher Rufo added the state totals. The sections on Qatar, the 2050 plan and schools reached us alongside the thread, and we could not confirm who wrote each one. We found none of this. Our contribution is the grading.

[DataRepublican's thread is here.](https://x.com/DataRepublican/status/1955360116007645428?ref=theunredacted.co) Our February report on the CAIR alumna running New York City's immigrant affairs office [is here](https://www.theunredacted.co/faiza-alis-appointment-connects-brooklyn-activism-cairs-institutional-reach-and-a-new-mayors-political-priorities/). This is the sixth report in our election series. The first [is here](https://www.theunredacted.co/Maga-smoked).

#### How to read this report

**Source data** blocks carry the record. Diamond blocks are **The Unredacted's** own read. Every claim is graded Observed Assessed Not established, and where our check came back different from the thread we mark it Corrected. CAIR has never been charged with a crime and denies every allegation of misuse described here. This report is about an organization and its documents. It is not about a religion.

1994A Palestine Committee agenda lists CAIR beside the Holy Land Foundationtrial exhibit, dated July 30

$41MIn public grants to CAIR California over five yearsCity Journal. Mostly federal pass-through

0Criminal charges against CAIR in 32 years. Audit findings on the grants: also noneas of this filing

§ 01 · The lineageChecks out

## The thread's core claim rests on documents the Justice Department put in front of a jury

##### Source data · the exhibits

Hamas's 1988 charter, article two, describes the movement as a wing of the Muslim Brotherhood in Palestine. Observed

In the Holy Land Foundation trial, prosecutors showed that the Brotherhood's American network ran a Palestine Committee to support Hamas, with three arms: the Islamic Association for Palestine for public work, the Holy Land Foundation for money, and a think tank, the United Association for Studies and Research. Omar Ahmad was the Islamic Association's president. Nihad Awad was its public relations director. Both attended a 1993 Philadelphia meeting of Hamas supporters that the FBI recorded. They founded CAIR the next year. Observed · trial record

A committee agenda dated July 30, 1994, Bates number ISE-SW 1B64/0000412, lists the "working organizations" to be reviewed. Four names appear: the three above, and CAIR. Observed · government exhibit

A jury convicted the Holy Land Foundation and five leaders in November 2008 of sending more than $12 million to Hamas. Sentences ran from 15 to 65 years. CAIR was named an unindicted co-conspirator. The trial judge later ruled that publishing the list violated the rights of those named, and in the same opinion wrote that the government had produced "ample evidence to establish the associations of CAIR" with the foundation and with Hamas. Observed · U.S. v. Holy Land Foundation

The FBI suspended formal contact with CAIR in 2008\. The United Arab Emirates listed it as a terrorist organization in 2014\. Observed

##### The Unredacted · what the paper proves

CAIR's founders came out of an organization the United States proved in court was built to serve Hamas, and a contemporaneous document from that network counts CAIR among its own. That is origin, and it is established as firmly as anything in this series.

It is also thirty-two years old. In that time prosecutors who had every incentive never charged CAIR, and the judge who found the evidence ample also found the public naming unlawful. A fair reader holds both facts. The thread's sentence "CAIR is Muslim Brotherhood" is a judgment about the present drawn from proof about the past. Assessed

§ 02 · The correctionsFive fixes

## Where the thread gets a fact wrong, and why it matters to get them right

| The thread says                                                           | The record says                                                                                                                                                    | Grade           |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | --------------- |
| The Islamic Association for Palestine was "convicted" of material support | It was never criminally charged. A civil jury found it liable in 2004 for the Hamas murder of American teenager David Boim, in a $156 million judgment             | Corrected       |
| CAIR took $250,000 from "an official Saudi bank"                          | The 1999 money came from the Islamic Development Bank, a multilateral lender based in Jeddah with dozens of member states                                          | Corrected       |
| Saudi prince Alwaleed bin Talal gave CAIR $500,000 in 2002                | Widely reported and not denied                                                                                                                                     | Observed        |
| Alwaleed, Mandalay Bay and the Las Vegas shooting                         | His company co-owns the Four Seasons brand, which operates floors of the tower. He was detained in a Saudi purge weeks later. Nothing connects either fact to CAIR | Not established |
| The "Explanatory Memorandum" states the Brotherhood's strategy            | A real 1991 exhibit by one member. No evidence at trial showed the network adopted it as policy                                                                    | Assessed        |
| The United States has not designated the Brotherhood                      | True when written. On January 13, 2026, the Egyptian, Jordanian and Lebanese chapters were designated                                                              | Corrected       |
| Washington avoids designation to protect politicians tied to CAIR         | A theory of motive. No document supports it                                                                                                                        | Not established |
| Qatar has spent "more than $93 billion" on influence                      | The Middle East Forum report puts documented spending near $40 billion. Its own line items add to that figure                                                      | Corrected       |

##### The Unredacted · the designation test

The thread's theory makes a prediction. Label the Brotherhood, and CAIR falls, and the politicians fall with it. In January the administration labeled three Brotherhood chapters. CAIR was not touched and no politician was implicated. Either the dominoes are not wired the way the thread says, or the administration chose chapters that would not reach them. Both readings are worth an editor's time. Neither has been reported out.

On the errors: a civil judgment for a murdered American boy is damning enough. Calling it a conviction hands CAIR's lawyers a false statement to wave at the judge. Assessed

§ 03 · QatarReal, with a limit

## The Qatar numbers mostly hold. Their connection to CAIR is never shown.

##### Source data · what checks out

The Quincy Institute's September 2025 brief matches the thread exactly: nearly $250 million on 88 registered lobbying and public relations firms since 2016, and 627 in-person meetings from January 2021 to June 2025, the most of any country. It also counts $6.25 billion to American universities since 2001\. Observed · Quincy Brief No. 83

The Middle East Forum documents more than $33.4 billion in business and real estate and about $72 million in lobbying. A Qatari royal invested roughly $50 million in Newsmax in 2019 and 2020\. Brookings took about $14 million from Qatar, and its president John Allen resigned in 2022 during a federal lobbying probe that closed without charges. Observed · MEF, Washington Post

Israel's military alleged in 2024 that six Al Jazeera journalists in Gaza were Hamas or Islamic Jihad operatives. The network denies it. The claim that campus activism tracks Qatari donations comes from a study showing correlation. Assessed

##### The Unredacted · two files stapled together

Qatar's spending is the best-documented foreign influence effort in Washington, and it reaches the right as well as the left. Our first report said so. What the thread does not supply is a single dollar, contract or email linking Doha to CAIR. Placing the two in one thread makes a reader assume the link. Our grade for that link is the same one we gave it last week. Not established

§ 04 · The 2050 planReal, with a limit

## Awad said it at a mosque. The mosque is also a CAIR subgrantee.

##### Source data · the speech

By published accounts of a 2025 address at the Islamic Society of Orange County, Awad described a fund in each of the country's 4,000 mosques to sponsor students in journalism, film, law, political science and history. His stated milestones: 50,000 in each field in twelve years and 100,000 "in the year 2050." Assessed · RAIR Foundation account of the video

An earlier account of a Texas speech described 100,000 in total. The thread's 400,000 is its own multiplication, and its fourth category, candidates, is not a figure we could find in the quoted remarks. Corrected

CAIR California's 2024 tax filing lists a $30,000 subgrant to the Islamic Society of Orange County. Observed · City Journal

##### The Unredacted · the plan is legal. That is the point.

A community deciding to raise its own journalists, lawyers and candidates is doing what Catholics, Jews, evangelicals and Mormons each did in their turn. Nothing in it is a crime, and the thread's word for the resulting candidates, "Jihadis," describes elected Democrats who won primaries. Use it and you have stopped reporting.

What makes the plan our business is the plumbing. The organization announcing a 25-year pipeline through mosques is the same one receiving federal grants, sub-granting to the mosque where the plan was announced, and funding campaigns through an affiliated super PAC. The thread asks what Republicans are doing in response. On the evidence of this series: hearings, and no equivalent. Assessed

§ 05 · The schoolsNeeds the work

## The bill named in the thread is a holiday bill

##### Source data · AB 2017 and the curriculum claims

California's AB 2017, by Assemblyman Matt Haney, is the State Holiday Act. It recognizes Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha, excuses absences for students who observe them, lets districts close if boards and unions agree, and allows a model curriculum guide. The co-sponsors are the three the thread names, CAIR California among them. The Legislature passed it. Observed · CAIR California fact sheet, California Globe

Neither the sponsor's fact sheet nor a critical account of the bill mentions the state's Holocaust and Genocide Education Grant Program or Gaza. If CAIR California has said it will press for that language, the statement is somewhere other than this bill. Corrected

Senator Tom Cotton wrote to the Education Secretary in September 2025 that CAIR's Philadelphia chapter was partnering with schools and had issued September 11 teaching guidance steering teachers away from terms such as "Islamic terrorists." Observed · Cotton letter

The lesson plans attributed to Teaching While Muslim, the 2026 back-to-school guide and the organizing advice about citizens and noncitizens are described in detail in the material we received. We could not open the originals. The claim that an older curriculum listed Osama bin Laden's letter rests on a dead link, as the material itself admits. Not established by us

##### The Unredacted · the sentence to strike

The schools section contains this: the curriculum is a problem "for the same reason that Islam is such a problem." Everything before that line is an argument about one organization's documents, money and politics. That line is an argument against a faith and the Americans who practice it. It is wrong, it is not ours, and it forfeits the case. Every exhibit in section one was assembled by federal prosecutors against specific defendants for specific acts. The moment the target becomes a religion, CAIR's standing defense, that its critics are bigots, becomes true of the critic.

A lesson that teaches children to ask whether "resistance" is terrorism can be judged on its text. So judge it on its text. Get the PDF, quote it, name the district that adopted it. Assessed

§ 06 · The moneyNeeds the work

## California paid CAIR to help 1,800 Afghan refugees. Watchdogs count 177\. CAIR says all of them.

Fig. 1 · Promised and counted

CONTRACT TARGET THROUGH SEPTEMBER 2024 1,800 AFGHAN CLIENTS UNIQUE AFGHAN CLIENTS IN RECORDS OBTAINED BY WATCHDOGS 177 · 9.8% CAIR's position: the 1,800 target was met across its subgrantees. Neither figure has been audited. 

Intelligent Advocacy Network and Network Contagion Research Institute analysis of public records; CAIR California statements reported by City Journal.

##### Source data · the grant file

CAIR California received more than $7.2 million in federal refugee money under grant ALSP22-0002, passed through the state. City Journal puts five-year awards at no less than $41 million, including $23 million in federal funds approved in September 2025\. Observed · congressional letter, City Journal

The watchdogs say state records show 177 unique Afghan clients against 1,800 promised, and that $3.6 million meant for independent providers went to CAIR's own Los Angeles office. CAIR says it met the target across subgrantees and that all funds are "fully reported, accounted for, and used strictly for their intended purposes." City Journal reported that the records did not confirm case counts. Assessed

CAIR California's director told a Senate committee in January that the group "had no input or role" in choosing subgrantees. The watchdogs produced contracts he signed. Fourteen House members asked for debarment in April. Health and Human Services announced a review in June. No finding has been published. Observed · New York Post, Roy letter, Post Millennial

##### The Unredacted · a correction to our own file

When this publication first worked the grant story in late 2025, we ran the 177 figure and a cost near $40,000 per client. A second pass could not trace the figure to a primary document, and that is still where it stands. One audit settles it. The state holds the deliverables and Washington holds the authority. The federal money kept flowing in 2025 under a Republican administration with a complaint already on file. Assessed

§ 07 · The loopReal, with a limit

## Public money in one door. Political money out another. Alumni in office.

##### Source data · the political arm and New York

CAIR Action put $185,000 this year into the Unity and Justice Fund, a super PAC. The fund gave $100,000 in 2025 to a committee backing Zohran Mamdani and $175,000 in July to one backing Abdul El-Sayed for Senate. Both won. After El-Sayed's primary a fund email claimed credit for building "a movement in Masjids." The phrase was removed within about two days of press coverage. Awad on politics: "If you want to have influence, you have to pay for it." Observed · FEC records via Washington Free Beacon

Faiza Ali worked at CAIR's New York chapter from 2007, rising to director of community affairs. She co-founded the Muslim Democratic Club of New York with Mamdani and on February 17, 2026 became commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs. Her city biography lists the CAIR post. Observed · NYC.gov, our February report

##### The Unredacted · what connects, and what does not

Our first report called this the machine: permanent organizations fed by public grants, with a legal wall between the charity that takes the money and the political arm that spends. Three limits, stated flatly. Nobody has shown a refugee dollar reaching a campaign. Ali left CAIR's New York chapter about a decade before the California grant existed and has no documented role in it. And no one has published which groups her office funds, so the claim that it favors CAIR-linked organizations is a question. Assessed

§ 08 · The graderLineage holds

## The whole file on one page

| Claim                                                          | Basis                                        | Grade           |
| -------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | --------------- |
| CAIR's founders came from Hamas's American support network     | Trial record, FBI surveillance               | Observed        |
| A 1994 Palestine Committee document lists CAIR                 | Government exhibit                           | Observed        |
| CAIR received foreign money                                    | Islamic Development Bank 1999, Alwaleed 2002 | Observed        |
| CAIR's political arm funded winning 2025 and 2026 campaigns    | FEC filings                                  | Observed        |
| CAIR California received $7.2 million in federal refugee money | Named grant                                  | Observed        |
| CAIR is the Muslim Brotherhood today                           | Inference from origin                        | Assessed        |
| Awad announced a 100,000-per-field plan for 2050               | Secondhand account of video                  | Assessed        |
| Only 177 of 1,800 refugees were served                         | Watchdog analysis, disputed, unaudited       | Assessed        |
| Qatar funds or directs CAIR                                    | No link offered                              | Not established |
| CAIR committed fraud                                           | No finding by any agency or court            | Not established |
| Refugee money paid for campaigns                               | No tracing published                         | Not established |
| AB 2017 funds Gaza genocide curricula                          | The bill is a holiday act                    | Not established |
| CAIR-backed candidates are jihadists                           | An insult, not a claim                       | Not established |

§ 09 · What to do about itStart now

## The thread says Republicans talk, hold hearings and tweet. Here is the alternative.

1. **Lead with the exhibit, not the adjective.** The July 30, 1994 agenda has a Bates number. The judge's opinion has a docket. Print them. A reader who sees the document needs no one to tell him what to think of it.
2. **Demand the refugee count, with a date.** Ask your member of Congress to request the audited number of Afghan clients served under grant ALSP22-0002\. One figure ends the argument in either direction.
3. **Fix the grant rule for everyone.** Per-client reporting, no sub-granting to a recipient's own offices, and a tax filing that matches the award. That catches every abuser, including ones the right likes.
4. **Ask who approved the 2025 money.** It went out under a Republican administration. Find the signature before blaming Sacramento alone.
5. **Pull the lesson plans.** File a records request with any district using outside curricula on the Middle East. Quote the PDF. Until then the schools claim is a description of documents nobody has shown.
6. **Build your own pipeline.** A 25-year plan to train journalists, lawyers and candidates through houses of worship is not sinister. It is competent. Churches and synagogues that want a say in 2050 can start the same fund on Sunday.
7. **Keep the religion out of it.** Millions of American Muslims have no part in CAIR and many oppose it. They are the allies this fight needs most and the first people a careless sentence drives away.

##### The short version

The documents against CAIR were written by its own founders and filed by federal prosecutors. They do not need help from anyone's anger.

The presidential election is two years out. One side has a plan with a date on it and a super PAC that has already won twice. The other has a thread. Turn the thread into records requests, a grant rule and a bench of your own, and say only what the paper says.

§ 10 · The bottom line

DataRepublican put the Holy Land exhibits back in front of the public, and they say what the thread says they say.

CAIR's origin inside Hamas's American network is observed. Its foreign money, its super PAC and its federal grants are observed. That it is the Brotherhood today, that Qatar stands behind it, that it committed fraud, and that refugee dollars reached a campaign are not established. Five facts in the thread needed correcting and one bill is not what it was said to be.

The line about Islam is struck. An investigation that cannot tell an organization from a faith is not one this publication will sign.

The rest stands on paper. Ask for it by exhibit number and by grant number.

Sponsored 

###### Grok Bot · Meet your AI teammates

You are invited to try Grok Bot, free for two weeks. Hand off real work and everyday tasks, and come back to them done.

[Start the free two weeks](https://grok.com/refer/bot?code=389XAG2AXWD4&ref=theunredacted.co) 

Referral link. The Unredacted earns credit if you sign up, at no cost to you. Sponsorships never touch editorial. Nothing in this report was reviewed by an advertiser.

##### Sourcing & method

Primary source under evaluation: DataRepublican's thread on X, read from text and two exhibit images supplied to us, together with further sections on Qatar, a 2050 plan and schools whose authorship we could not confirm. Checked against: the trial record in U.S. v. Holy Land Foundation and the district court's 2009 opinion on the co-conspirator list; Boim v. Quranic Literacy Institute; the Quincy Institute's Brief No. 83; the Middle East Forum's Qatar report; the Foundation for Defense of Democracies on the January 2026 Brotherhood designations; RAIR Foundation's account of the Awad speech; CAIR California's AB 2017 fact sheet and California Globe; Senator Cotton's September 2025 letter; the April 2026 Roy letter; City Journal; the New York Post; The Post Millennial; Washington Free Beacon reporting on FEC filings; and this publication's research files.

Limits stated plainly. We have not viewed the Awad video, the Teaching While Muslim lessons or CAIR's school guide, and grade them accordingly. We did not check FEC records for the thread's claim about a donation to a member of Congress and do not repeat it. Dollar totals for the California grants differ by source. CAIR and CAIR California deny all allegations of misuse. Commissioner Ali is not accused of wrongdoing.