We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.Elie Wiesel (1986)

On November 19, 2025, approximately 200 protesters assembled outside Park East Synagogue on Manhattan's Upper East Side. The demonstration, organized by the Palestinian Assembly for Liberation-AWDA NY/NJ, targeted an informational event inside where Nefesh B'Nefesh was helping American Jews learn about immigration to Israel. Attendees entering the synagogue were met with chants of "Death to the IDF," "globalize the intifada," and shouted slurs including "f—king Jewish pricks." Police separated protesters and counter-protesters but did not halt the demonstration.

What happened next revealed more about New York City's political future than the protest itself.

Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani's spokesperson issued a statement that acknowledged the language used at the protest was problematic—then added a critical qualifier. "He believes every New Yorker should be free to enter a house of worship without intimidation," press secretary Dora Pekec stated, "and that these sacred spaces should not be used to promote activities in violation of international law." The statement reframed a routine aliyah information session as potentially illicit, echoing the demonstrators' own justification for their presence outside the synagogue.

The response pattern is instructive. When a swastika was painted on a Brooklyn yeshiva after Mamdani's election, he immediately offered a full-throated denunciation on social media. When "F–k Jews" appeared on a Brooklyn sidewalk, he again quickly condemned it. But when demonstrators surrounded a synagogue shouting death threats, Mamdani did not make a public comment himself. His office's statement did not address allegations of antisemitism. The difference: in the first two incidents, there was no policy dimension to complicate the moral clarity.

Following the money reveals who shaped Mamdani's path to City Hall. Campaign finance records show his campaign paid over $28,000 to the New York City Democratic Socialists of America in September 2025 alone—by far the largest contribution to the group since his campaign launched. Total payments to NYC-DSA exceeded $33,000 across 36 separate transactions. DSA organizer Daniel Goulden publicly boasted about the organization's intimate involvement in Mamdani's campaign, claiming they helped write portions of his platform and maintained "regular meetings" with the mayor-elect and his team.

The relationship runs deeper than donations. Mamdani has been a member of NYC-DSA since before his 2020 election to the State Assembly. During a 2021 interview, he revealed that supporting the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement was a requirement for receiving DSA's endorsement: "Within the questionnaire when you submit to be considered a candidate to be endorsed by the organization, you're asked what your views are on BDS." NYC-DSA celebrated his mayoral victory as "the most monumental electoral victory for the US socialist movement in the last century" and mobilized 8,800 members who volunteered as field leads and organized phone banks across all five boroughs.

Al-Awda, the organization that led the Park East demonstration, operates from Coral Springs, Florida, and has been active across the United States for over two decades. The Anti-Defamation League classifies Al-Awda as an extreme anti-Zionist organization whose "Points of Unity" statement declares that "racism and discrimination are inherent in Zionist ideology." According to NGO Monitor, Al-Awda organized an antisemitic riot in Brooklyn's Boro Park neighborhood in February 2025, encouraging participants to "Flood Boro Park"—a reference to Hamas's name for the October 7 massacre, the "Al-Aqsa Flood." The organization has publicly praised "resistance in all its forms" and described convicted terrorists as "freedom fighters."

Mamdani's voting record during his tenure in the State Assembly provides additional context. He sponsored legislation aimed at blocking nonprofits from funding Israeli settlements—legislation that critics, including opponents of the settlement movement, described as casting an overly broad net. During his mayoral campaign, he initially declined to condemn the phrase "globalize the intifada," later shifting to say he would merely "discourage" its use. He has called Israel's conduct in Gaza "genocide" and pledged to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he visits New York City, despite the United States not being a member of the International Criminal Court.

The contrast between Mamdani's response and those of other New York leaders was stark. Governor Kathy Hochul called the demonstration "shameful and a blatant attack on the Jewish community." Outgoing Mayor Eric Adams termed it "antisemitic" and warned, "Today it's a synagogue. Tomorrow it's a church or a mosque." Representative Ritchie Torres stated that targeting a synagogue "is not criticism, it's extremism" and amounts to discrimination.

Park East Synagogue's cantor, Benny Rogosnitzky, described the experience as "very scary." He told CNN that "people coming in to services or to the event felt intimidated." Rabbi Arthur Schneier, Park East's senior rabbi, is a Holocaust survivor. The historical weight of protesters surrounding a synagogue led by someone who witnessed Kristallnacht was not lost on Jewish community leaders. Rabbi Elchanan Poupko noted in a viral social media post: "The Rabbi of the synagogue is a holocaust survivor who remembers vividly the horrors of Kristallnacht. Now, he gets to see the same human material that shattered the glass of synagogues in Berlin and Vienna in 1938, outside his own synagogue."

The Anti-Defamation League launched a "Mamdani Monitor" to track the mayor-elect's policies and appointments. CNN exit polls found that approximately 64% of Jewish voters cast their ballots for former Governor Andrew Cuomo, running as an independent, while only one-third voted for Mamdani—despite New York's Jewish community generally supporting progressive policies. Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch challenged Mamdani to prove wrong his assessment that the mayor-elect's criticisms of Israel aligned with Hamas's objectives. "If I'm wrong, say so," Hirsch told CNN. "It would be welcomed by the American Jewish community, by the New York Jewish community, and by many people who are not Jewish who care about these issues." A month later, the challenge remained unanswered.

After public backlash, Mamdani's team issued a revised statement declaring that "nothing can justify language calling for 'death to' anyone. It is unacceptable, full stop." Notably, this clarification omitted any criticism of the synagogue or reference to violations of international law. The revision came only after prominent Jewish leaders raised alarms and New York lawmakers introduced legislation to ban demonstrations within 25 feet of houses of worship.

The sequence matters: qualified condemnation, public outcry, unqualified statement. The question facing New York's Jewish community is whether leadership that requires pressure to reach moral clarity can be trusted to protect their safety when the pressure isn't applied.

What Remains Unanswered: Does Mamdani believe he has authority to enforce "international law" against organizations operating in New York City? Will his administration instruct the NYPD to monitor or investigate groups like Nefesh B'Nefesh? And most critically, will the distinction between vandalism targeting Jewish property and organized intimidation outside synagogues persist in future city responses?

Those questions will be answered starting January 1, 2026, when Mamdani takes office as New York City's first Muslim mayor, backed by the most powerful democratic socialist organization in the country and facing a Jewish community that voted overwhelmingly against him.

Share this article
The link has been copied!