Do Not Divide the Dead: Mamdani's Soviet Answer on October 7
Watch Zohran Mamdani squirm and stutter when Andrew Ross Sorkin asks him why he couldn't simply condemn October 7th and criticize Israel the following day.
— Yehuda Teitelbaum (@chalavyishmael) November 19, 2026
It's such a basic question, and Mamdani cannot bring himself to answer it. Instead, he launches into a lecture about… pic.twitter.com/uergo8tjLB
THE UNREDACTED
Essay · NYC Politics
Mamdani Was Asked to Give Jews One Day. He Gave Them a Lecture on Genocide.
At the DealBook Summit, Andrew Ross Sorkin asked the mayor to mark October 7 on its own and save Israel for October 8. The room applauded. The mayor explained why that is impossible.
The loudest applause of Zohran Mamdani's hour at the DealBook Summit on Wednesday went to a question about the calendar.
Until then the mayor was having a good morning. He walked onstage at Lincoln Center, looked out at a hall of bankers, fund managers and chief executives, and greeted them as "comrades." He called it the largest DSA meeting Lincoln Center had ever seen. The room laughed the way rich people laugh at a joke about their own taxes. For a while he took Andrew Ross Sorkin's questions about Trump, the wealthy and city-run grocery stores with the ease of a man who has learned to reassure the people he plans to tax.
Then Sorkin brought up language.
He reminded the mayor that Jews are the targets of more than half the hate crimes in New York City, and asked about the statement Mamdani posted on the third anniversary of October 7. It opened with a few lines of mourning for the victims of Hamas, then gave most of its length to accusing Israel of "ongoing genocide" and "apartheid." Ben Shapiro did the arithmetic. The post drew condemnation from UJA-Federation, from Israel's consul general in New York and from members of Congress.
The October 7 Statement, by Word Count
Mamdani's first answer was smooth. The post, he said, did not cover his whole day. He had attended a vigil and been protested there. His politics, he said, "believes that there has to be room to mourn everyone." Then came the line he has used all year: "I'm also proud to be the mayor of the most Jewish city in the United States of America." He even corrected Sorkin's statistic. Jews, he said, are 10 to 12 percent of the city and more than half of its hate-crime victims. "You have to root out antisemitism."
Sorkin did not move on. He asked something much simpler: whether the mayor would ever consider sending one tweet on October 7 about how terrible that day was, and waiting until October 8 to say how terrible he thinks Israel has handled the war.
The hall broke into applause. Sorkin acknowledged it from the stage, and allowed that some in the room would not be clapping. For a moment Mamdani looked as uncomfortable as he has looked in public since taking office. He started an answer, dropped it, and started again.
Mamdani: Let me say it this way. When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given, no matter what day that it's asked about, will be the relationship to October 7. My point being, this is a day that is not only a horrific war crime, it is also a day that has been used as a justification for all that followed it.
Sorkin: But you get the other side of that argument, too.
Mamdani: I do. I do. I get the other side.
Sorkin: But you've decided that putting them together is better.
Mamdani: I have a politics of universality. … That is who I am. That's who I'll always be.
Twenty-Four Hours
Sorkin asked for twenty-four hours. The mayor explained why Jews cannot have them.
New York suspends alternate-side parking for Yom Kippur without attaching a position paper on the Middle East. The mayor of that same city could not give the murdered of October 7 a single day to themselves.
His reason is the heart of the problem. In Mamdani's telling, October 7 is a war crime and also "a justification for all that followed it." The massacre becomes Israel's alibi. The worst single-day slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust stops being a day with victims and becomes an exhibit in a case against the victims' own state. Universality would mean something else entirely. It would mean the dead of October 7 receive what any other group of murdered civilians gets from a New York mayor: one day on which nobody uses them to make a point.
It is also a principle that, so far, has only been tested in one direction. It obliges the mayor to bring up Gaza on the anniversary of a massacre of Jews. It would be worth knowing whether it equally obliges him to bring up the hostages taken by Hamas when he marks days of Palestinian grief. A reporter at his next press availability might ask.
Then there was "I get the other side." He said it while doing the opposite of what the other side had just asked for, with the applause still fading. Understanding an objection and setting it aside in the same breath is a real political skill, and the mayor showed considerable talent for it.
The Word Nobody Challenged
Sorkin let "genocide" stand. He pressed on tone and timing, and never asked on what basis the mayor of the largest Jewish city outside Israel was accusing the Jewish state of genocide, in a hall full of Jewish New Yorkers, in answer to a question about Jewish grief. That was the moment for a follow-up, and the moderator let it pass.
It matters because words from City Hall do not stay at Lincoln Center. Nobody asked Mamdani to change his view of the war. Critics asked for one day. When the mayor of a city where Jews are more than half of hate-crime victims answers that request with "genocide," he is not adding a footnote to a policy debate. He is telling the people who carry most of the city's hate crimes that their grief is conditional, and that the condition is Israel.
A Division of Labor
Set the two halves of the interview side by side. In the first, Mamdani is proud to lead the most Jewish city in America and promises to root out antisemitism. In the second, he explains that Jewish mourning cannot stand on its own for a single day. Some will call that a contradiction. It works more like a division of labor.
One Interview, Two Kinds of Jew
| Jews as individuals | Jews as a people | |
|---|---|---|
| What the mayor said | "Proud to be the mayor of the most Jewish city" | "I have a politics of universality" |
| What City Hall offers | A hotline, security camera reimbursements, $1.25M for Holocaust education | A shared day of mourning, with Israel on the agenda |
| October 7 is | "A horrific war crime" | "A justification for all that followed it" |
A mayor who spent the morning assuring billionaires there is room for them in his New York could not find room on the calendar for the Jewish dead.
The same week shows how this plays out on the street. Two days before DealBook, Mamdani announced he was disbanding the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, the unit of roughly 500 officers that has policed the city's large protests, including three years of demonstrations over Israel. He announced it in a video with Councilman Chi Ossé, shortly after a New York City DSA convention passed a resolution demanding exactly that. Mamdani told reporters the new civilian division's staff would start "at about 30," civilians "without weapons or arrest powers." In a city where Jews are more than half of hate-crime victims, the front line of protest response is now thirty civilians with no weapons, no arrest powers and, presumably, a great deal of patience.
Who Shows Up When the Protest Starts
| Before | After | |
|---|---|---|
| Front-line unit | Strategic Response Group (NYPD) | Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (civilian) |
| Size | Roughly 500 officers | Starting at about 30 staff |
| Weapons and arrest powers | Yes | None |
| Police backup | Built in | 30-officer First Amendment Support Team |
| When arrests are needed | SRG | A patrol support division is called in |
| Counterterrorism | SRG | NYPD Counterterrorism Bureau |
Sources: Mayor's Office transcript, NY1, NBC New York, Middle East Eye.
Six Weeks at City Hall
- Oct. 7Mayor marks the third anniversary of the massacre with a post accusing Israel of "ongoing genocide" and "apartheid."
- Oct. 8Asked about the backlash, he declines to walk any of it back.
- Nov. 16SRG disbanded, announced in a video with Councilman Chi Ossé after a DSA convention resolution.
- Nov. 18At DealBook, asked to give October 7 one day on its own, he explains his "politics of universality."
Do Not Divide the Dead
People who grew up in the Soviet Union have heard this before. In September 1941, German units shot 33,771 Jews over two days at Babi Yar, a ravine on the edge of Kyiv. For decades afterward the Soviet state made sure the word "Jew" never appeared there. The monument that finally went up in 1976 honored murdered citizens of Kyiv and prisoners of war. When Jewish families asked why their dead could not be named as Jews, officials had a stock reply: ne delite mertvykh, do not divide the dead. The same state had outlawed antisemitism by decree in 1918 and called itself the world's great enemy of bigotry. It also suppressed the Black Book of the Holocaust and, after 1967, ran a propaganda campaign branding Zionism the new Nazism. Moscow saw no conflict in any of it. Hatred of Jews as individuals was a crime. Jewish memory as a people was a political problem to be managed. The Kremlin called that internationalism, and Mamdani calls it universality.
- 1918Lenin's government decrees antisemitism a crime.
- 194133,771 Jews shot at Babi Yar in two days.
- 1976Soviet monument rises. The plaque names "citizens" and "prisoners of war." It does not name Jews.
- 1991A menorah is finally placed over the ravine. The Soviet Union ends the same year.
Kyiv's Jews waited fifty years for the menorah that now stands over the ravine. On Wednesday a room at Lincoln Center applauded a simple request for one day. The mayor gave the answer those families heard in Kyiv.
Receipts
- DealBook Summit exchange, Nov. 18, 2026: transcript; VIN News
- October 7, 2026 statement, "ongoing genocide" and "apartheid": Times of Israel; reaction from UJA-Federation: Jewish Insider; Shapiro's word count: IBTimes; declining to walk it back: Fox News
- Antisemitic incidents at 53.9% of NYC hate crimes; $1.25 million to the Museum of Jewish Heritage: CBS New York
- SRG disbanded; civilian division "starting at about 30": Mayor's Office transcript; NY1; NBC New York
- SRG size of roughly 500 officers: Middle East Eye; DSA resolution preceding the announcement: Washington Free Beacon