The Dabke and the Double Standard: How New York's Schools Became a Pipeline for Foreign Influence

There is a particular quality of cognitive dissonance that overtakes a society in the late stages of its self-erasure. It does not arrive as a thunderclap. It comes quietly, cheerfully, dressed in folk costume and set to the rhythm of stomping feet.

At P.S. 107 in Park Slope, Brooklyn, elementary school children were recently seated in a circle to watch and participate in a performance of Dabke, the traditional Levantine line dance, as part of Arab American Heritage Month. The PTA filmed it. They posted it proudly. The caption celebrated "rhythm and heritage." And perhaps, if one turned away from everything else happening in the New York City public school system, it might have appeared innocuous. Children, color, percussion, joy.

But context, as Orwell understood, is everything. What happened at P.S. 107 was not a spontaneous celebration of diversity. It was a small, precise illustration of a transformation that has been methodically engineered across American institutions for years. New York City's new administration is not merely permitting that transformation. It is accelerating it.

Let us be precise about what tolerance looks like in practice in New York's public schools. A Christian student who displays a nativity scene risks administrative censure. A teacher who mentions Christmas with anything approaching warmth courts accusations of impropriety. The separation of church and state, a doctrine originally designed to prevent government from establishing a national religion, has been quietly reinterpreted into something rather different: a mechanism for the systematic exclusion of Judeo-Christian expression from public life, while leaving the door conspicuously open for others.

Prayer accommodations during Ramadan are extended without controversy across multiple New York schools. Zaffa processions, Dabke workshops, full sensory immersion into Levantine cultural traditions during school hours are celebrated, filmed, and posted to Instagram. Meanwhile, Christian student groups have spent years in federal court simply to use empty school buildings after hours for worship, and have frequently lost. This is not neutrality. It is a hierarchy, written in policy and enforced by the selective application of principle.

One might note, as an outside observer, that this precise inversion has already played out across Western Europe. The mechanism is familiar. Multiculturalism as asymmetric obligation, in which the host civilization is asked to subordinate its own expressions while remaining scrupulously non-judgmental about all incoming ones. The results in Britain and France and the Netherlands have not been the harmonious pluralism promised. But Americans, characteristically, prefer to learn their lessons fresh.

Which brings us to the money.

In April 2025, the Ambassador of Qatar paid a visit to the United States Secretary of Education. He was, remarkably, the only foreign ambassador to do so that year. One could dismiss this as diplomatic routine, the ordinary commerce of international relations. One could. But one would then need to explain why Qatari funding to American universities tripled to over $1.1 billion in 2025, making Qatar the single largest foreign donor to American higher education that year. Cornell. Carnegie Mellon. Texas A&M. Georgetown. These are not obscure institutions. They are the incubators of the administrators, curriculum designers, and teachers who populate, in due course, every layer of American public education.

Qatar Foundation International and its state-linked affiliates have not been funding these institutions out of a disinterested love of learning. They fund programs that produce, with considerable reliability, a particular orientation toward the Arab world, toward Islamic political movements, and toward the conflict in the Middle East. The pipeline runs from Doha to the faculty lounge to the lesson plan and eventually to a circle of kindergarteners in Park Slope, watching Dabke dancers and being told this is what heritage looks like. Former American education officials have been retained as paid consultants to defend precisely these funding arrangements. The word that comes to mind is not conspiracy. It is something more banal and therefore more durable. Institutional capture.

It would be remiss not to note that this capture is operating under particularly favorable conditions in New York City. Since January 1, 2026, the city's Department of Education has functioned under an administration whose ideological affinities with the activist networks championing this programming are not incidental. Mayor Zohran Mamdani's appointees and allied organizations, many of them embedded in the DSA-adjacent, pro-BDS infrastructure that has shaped New York's progressive left, are not neutral stewards of a pluralist institution. They are participants in a broader project, and the schools are one of its instruments.

The Arab American Heritage Month programming that generated the P.S. 107 video is not a rogue local initiative. It reflects DOE-curated resources, teacher guides, and digital library materials developed and promoted across the system. It exists within an ideological ecosystem in which Palestinian cultural symbols function simultaneously as political ones, in which performers from groups like Dalouna Events bring the aesthetics of resistance into classrooms full of children who cannot yet read, let alone critically evaluate what they are absorbing.

De Tocqueville, observing the young American republic in 1835, wrote that Americans had fused the notions of Christianity and liberty so thoroughly in their minds that they could not conceive of one without the other. He meant this as a sociological observation, not a theological one. He was describing the civilizational grammar through which Americans understood freedom, law, and self-governance. That grammar is not being translated in today's New York City classrooms. It is being replaced.

George Washington, in his Farewell Address, warned against the insidious wiles of foreign influence, the slow working of external powers on the soul of the republic. He did not envision Qatar. He did not need to. The mechanism he feared is universal. Foreign money, foreign ideology, and foreign cultural programming, operating through apparently benign institutions, gradually redirecting the loyalties and assumptions of a new generation.

The parents filming the Dabke performance at P.S. 107 were not bad people. They were doing what comfortable, well-meaning people in prosperous neighborhoods tend to do. They assumed the institutions around them were functioning normally, that the programming their children received was innocent, that anyone raising concerns was simply lacking in generosity of spirit. This is precisely what makes institutional capture so effective. It relies not on coercion but on the social cost of noticing.

The question before New York and before the country is not whether folk dance is sinister. It is not. The question is whether public schools that ban the Nativity and police Christmas carols can coherently justify immersive cultural programming in Levantine tradition, funded at the university level by the world's most aggressive foreign donor to American higher education, administered by a municipal government whose ideological commitments are anything but neutral.

The answer, stated plainly, is no. The refusal to state it plainly, the retreat into niceness and the performance of open-mindedness and the social safety of not asking questions, is not tolerance. It is abdication.

Western civilization has a word for the moment when a society becomes unable to articulate what it values and why. The word is decadence. New York's public schools are not there yet. But Park Slope's PTA Instagram account suggests they are further along than most people are prepared to admit.

DSA is like MAO’s Red Guard, and they just passed 100,000 Members

This Saturday, as an armed man stormed the White House Correspondents’ Dinner and tried to kill the President of the United States, I could not help but think that if this were a dozen IRGC commandos and not a 31-year-old teacher from California, the results could have been very tragic

The Unredacted | Truth Without PermissionGene Goodwin